Pet journalist Jeff Yang posted a video on Twitter showing his dog Aiko pawing and nipping at her cat sibling. Moments later, the dog tumbles to the floor and Twitter users are debating whether the cat was responsible.

If you watch the video, the cat appears largely innocent and the dog seems to lean too far back and tip the chair over. Then again, cats are devious enough to make you think they’re innocent when they really set up others to fail and blame themselves because that’s just how cats are.

To judge for yourself if the cat is innocent or not, click here.